DP’s Law Blog


Mental Health Courts 
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

Mental Health Courts 

By Pearl Bakhtiari, Articling Student Mental health courts are in place as a response to the challenges faced by those who struggle with their mental health and consequently, the law. They allow for a more effective and rehabilitative approach to address the legal issues that arise due to mental health struggles. These courts have specialized staff, including mental health support workers, psychiatrists, and specially trained Crowns, Duty Counsel and Judges.

Read More
Time-Served for Driving Prohibitions
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

Time-Served for Driving Prohibitions

By Jason Ruggeberg, Law student. In Canada, an impaired driving conviction comes with a mandatory minimum driving prohibition of one year. However, even before being charged, the offender is liable to an automatic 90-day license suspension under the Ontario Highway Traffic Act (HTA). A court-ordered prohibition on driving lasting until their charges are resolved may also be imposed as a condition of their release, although this is relatively rare in Ontario.

Read More
Defending Sexual Violence Part 1: The Twin Myths under s. 276
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

Defending Sexual Violence Part 1: The Twin Myths under s. 276

By Jocelyn Heaton, Articling Student. The Criminal Code contains various provisions that limit an accused person's ability to adduce certain evidence for certain offences. S. 276 of the criminal code prohibits the admission of sexual history evidence unless it (1) is relevant to an issue at trial (2) is of specific, as opposed to broad or general, sexual activity, (3) has significant probative value not outweighed by prejudice to the complaint, and (4) proved to not perpetuate the twin myths.

Read More
A Year of Sentencing at the Supreme Court of Canada
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

A Year of Sentencing at the Supreme Court of Canada

By Jocelyn Heaton, Articling Student One of the most important aspects of criminal law for accused persons is their sentencing, determining what sanctions are to be placed upon them, and for how long. However, due to the nature of sentencing case law, requiring sentencing judges be given significant deference on appeal, it is not common that we see sentencing cases make their way to the Supreme Court. However, in March of 2022, four sentencing cases did just that, leading to significant media attention on issues of sentencing. But what actually happened in these cases and what are the impacts on accused persons rights?

Read More
Zoom Links & Daily Dockets
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

Zoom Links & Daily Dockets

By Ryan Conway, Summer Student Zoom court is relatively new to Ontario. Here are your questions answered on how to attend including finding your courtroom link online.

Read More
Protecting Your Right to be Tried within a Reasonable Time – The (Potential) Obligation to Follow Up
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

Protecting Your Right to be Tried within a Reasonable Time – The (Potential) Obligation to Follow Up

By Tiffany Phan, Summer Student As a case moves along towards trial, there are certain actions each side must take to ensure that key milestones are reached (e.g., disclosure is vetted by the Crown and released to the defendant; the disclosure is reviewed by the defendant; a Crown Pre-trial is scheduled and held; a Judicial Pre-Trial is scheduled and held; trial dates are canvased and scheduled). When these milestones take longer to reach than expected, the delay will usually be attributed to one side.

Read More
The Duty of the Crown to Mitigate Delay: Severance and 11(b)
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

The Duty of the Crown to Mitigate Delay: Severance and 11(b)

In a recent case, the Superior Court of Justice was forced to consider two important competing interests: society’s interest in co-accused participating in a joint trial and the 11(b) rights of individual accused. In this case, after awaiting trial for three years, our client, Mr. Smith, and his co-accused, Mr. Douse, faced a potential further year-long delay due to the actions of the Crown and a second co-accused, Mr. Sitladeen, who had fled to the United States prior to his arrest.

Read More
The Counsel Table Debate: A Principled Approach by Justice Schreck
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

The Counsel Table Debate: A Principled Approach by Justice Schreck

By Jordyn Cowley, Associate The placement of an accused person in the courtroom during his or her trial has been a longstanding topic of debate in the Ontario Superior Court of Justice. In our recent case, R. v. Douse and Smith, 2022 ONSC 3163, the Honourable Justice Schreck took the opportunity to comment on the issue and clarify a principled approach.

Read More
Can the Police Search my Phone?
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

Can the Police Search my Phone?

By Carolina Salles Quaresma, Articling Student Nowadays we have literally the world in our hands. With a cell phone in hand, we can talk to anyone anywhere in the world, we can deposit a cheque, we can record a video, take a photo of a special moment. Access to private information such as bank account, photos, videos, can be potentially dangerous if in others’ hands.

Read More
How to Support Yourself and Your Loved One When They’re in Prison
Katie Dolan Katie Dolan

How to Support Yourself and Your Loved One When They’re in Prison

By Carimé Boehr, Articling Student When a loved one is incarcerated, it profoundly impacts more than just the person stepping into prison. In a report based on a 2014 survey prepared at Wilfrid Laurier University, the results revealed that “families with a loved one incarcerated experience more distress on average than the general population.”

Read More